Saturday, December 11, 2010
Appeal of a Narrative
Favorite Blog
Research Question/Topic
My research looks at the global narrative of the feminicidios occurring in Juarez, Mexico and how the feminicidios and the “Big G”, globalization, are interdependent.
appeal of narrative and citizen sharing
Narratives were throughout history were published in various forms, through books, newspapers, magazines, and now the worldwide web. Narratives provide readers with a perspective that allows for many other perspectives and the creation of other narrations. With all that information that is now provided to publishers it is now up to them to pick and choose what is going to be available for the public eye. At times these organizations do not pick the correct information to share and the wrong information is distributed
One of the most important aspects of narratives is the editor. The editor takes the information that the writer established and edits it is passed down to citizens the correct way.With the evolution of the internet it has become much easier for people to find information out and spread it as well. Now people use facebook and twitter as well as other social networks. These social networks do not work well because wrong information can be passed down and that is not the correct way to go about it.
Thursday, December 9, 2010
Research Question
A Discussion on the Chinese Government’s Internet Censorship and its Effect in Fostering the Cyber Nationalism
Wednesday, December 8, 2010
Citizen Journalism and Global Awareness
The Appeal of Global Narratives
Cited:
Fischer, Annemarie. Class Discussion. “Global Media Narratives,” Binghamton University.
Research Question
The Appeal of Narrative and Citizen Sharing
The difference today is that people can spread the news themselves by posting status updates and sharing news by the article instead of the paper. Appealing narratives can be derived from what is worth sharing instead of what will be sold. The editors no longer have to judge if a particular story is interesting to the public, as a significant sample size of the public can share it by itself and the editors can then highlight that story for the rest of the public. The pre-digital editors job was to tap into the pulse of the public by measuring sales, but now they can tap directly into the blood stream by monitoring click-through rates and the sharing of articles.
Have we seen a complete overhaul in what narratives become popular? Largely no. It is the same reporting on "things that are shocking" like international war that we have seen before, but now the focus can be shifted to the places that might have been overlooked in the past. When there were protests in Iran in June 2009, the New York Times and CNN, didn't cover the start of the protests. Only after reports of the protests took the Internet by storm, major news organizations started to cover the events. The audience now has more control than ever as to what gets covered and becomes a narrative, but the appeal is the same. There is no true definition of what is newsworthy, but it usually comes down to a few things; the shocking, the inspirational, and the relevant to ones' life. And ultimately, what would you want a friend to know?
What is a Narrative
Works Cited
Abbott, H. Porter. The Cambridge Introduction to Narrative. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2008. Print.
Herman, David. The Cambridge Companion to Narrative. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2007. Print.
What is Globalization?
Works Cited
Norris, Pippa. "Information Poverty and the Wired World." The Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics. Vol. 5, No. 3, (2003)
The "Aura" and "Media Industry" in Cyberspace
Adorno describes the industry of culture as "infecting everything with sameness" (Adorno 1). He is arguing that through the growth of media such as television and radio, more people are receiving the same message. At first glance this would appear to be a culture, but on closer inspection it is revealed as a business. If everyone likes the same thing, whoever is selling that thing will be making a lot of money. Therefore, the media industry revolves around selling items to mass groups of people. When the masses are large enough, the product begins to define them. At the same time, they feel as if they are making the choice between all the products placed in front of them. However, they are still confined in the same media bubble, being forced to align with one group or another.
Works Cited
Benjamin, Walter. Illuminations. New York: Schoken Books, 1968.
Horkeimer, Max and Adorno, Theodor. Dialectic of Enlightenment. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2002.
Favorite Blog
Tuesday, December 7, 2010
Research Question
Sunday, December 5, 2010
Research Question and Topic Title
How news and media can mislead and misinform people on financial fact and investment ideas, and how this can potentially lead to a deterioration of financial education found in Colleges and Universities?
Research Topic:
Media Misinterpretation: Reason amidst Financial Madness
Tuesday, November 30, 2010
Research Paper Topic
Monday, November 29, 2010
Research Question
Research topic:
The Appeal of Narratives in the Digital Age: A Look Into the Shifts of Public Interest
Research Project
Sunday, November 28, 2010
Favorite blog
Research Question
Can citizen journalism and/or cyber technology raise global awareness?
Saturday, November 27, 2010
Tuesday, November 23, 2010
Research Question:
How hip hop music/ rap affect the society? not only focus on money, sex...but also more politically
1, America
2, Asia Country (mostly force in Chinese)
3, Differences between
Monday, November 22, 2010
Research Question
Research Topic
Research Question
Even though the Pakistani floods had more people affected than the Haiti Earthquake and Indian ocean Tsunami combined, how come it received no where near the media attention as the other two events mentioned above?
(I also e-mailed this question the day it was due)
Sunday, November 21, 2010
Research Question
Research Question
Research Question
Is the over-censorization and hidden agendas of today's current media sources causing people to shy away from mass media and turn instead their focus to micro media and social networking?
Saturday, November 20, 2010
Research Question
Thursday, November 18, 2010
Research Question
Wednesday, November 17, 2010
Can citizen journalism and/or cyber technology raise global awareness?
As such, citizen journalism is in its prime. And because it's better than its ever been, it has the power to raise global awareness.
My Research Idea
I will also be examining Freud's writings on mourning and melancholia, in order to make sense of the fan hysteria over the loss of Michael Jackson, especially the twelve suicides that took place around the world after his passing.
Appeal of a Narrative
Appeal of Narratives
Humans are social beings, most of our daily activities involve communicating or correlating with others; either physically through direct contact or indirectly using the various forms of communication we have. There are always stories being told or heard, the rate at which these stories or narratives are produced and received has only increased with advancement in technology. Unfortunately, our brains are pretty much the same size they were hundreds of years ago. We are not evolving at a rapid pace, if at all, and thanks to modern medicine; natural selection is barely present. So how do we deal with all this information being flooded into our brains when we can’t possibly absorb everything due to our biological restrictions?
Well, slowly people have adapted to where they have become more selective in what they care about as a society, if something seems uninteresting then it will go right through their ears without ever being taken into consideration. And I can see why this happens! Because it is necessary! This creates a fine line between narratives which are appealing and ones which aren’t. A lot of people have the misconception that somehow our media is changing how we as Americans think what exactly is being delivered to us; they are partially right in a sense but not completely. Yes the attempts to manufacture consent are there and always have been, but people also have the ability to choose for themselves. In an interview; Michael Moore stated that it was because of various political powers that our media is losing its value and that it’s all about big bold pictures and colorful letters, but what he failed to see is that production is directly correlated to demand. Big bold letters are easy to see! Pictures say more than words usually can. Magazines and newspapers use big bold letters now because that is what people prefer.
A prime example of this is the Darfur conflict and violence in Middle East. Hundreds and hundreds of women have been raped or murdered in the past few years in Darfur, yet it is rarely ever mentioned in the news or on TV, but when an attractive Iranian woman was shot shot it was all over the news. I read a comment where someone said that apparently it was due to her westernization and that people care when a westernized Middle Eastern woman is shot. But I personally think that it could be the simple fact that the video of her death was actually recorded using a good quality camera and was posted on YouTube. Last time I checked, YouTube did not have a video of an African woman being killed for her difference in ideology or beliefs, so maybe Africa when modernized will eventually appear on the news. Africa is disconnected in a sense from the rest of the world, it’s very hard to get reporters out there due to the dangers involved.
Also the political parties in America understand that they must deal with one region at a time, if they were to intervene in Darfur right now it will put even more pressure on our already fragile economy, making us venerable to other world powers such as China or Russia. So there is definitely some strategic ignorance being manufactured but if it wasn’t for the high demand it would not be able to survive for long. After 9/11, Middle East and Arabs in general have become a topic of discussion and until something else were to happen; we will have a hard time diverting our limited attention elsewhere. The narrative of Iran and Middle East relates to us directly, they are trying to acquire nuclear weapons which could possibly become a threat to all of us. Even if an all out war in Africa were to break out, it will never reach our borders. This makes the narrative of Neda more appealing than the narrative of Darfur. I am not saying people are selfish and that they only care about things which affect them; it is very possible that if videos such as Neda’s were posted online from Africa, it might spark wide support for intervention. But right now there just isn’t enough awareness about the issue out there.
Sources
1- Moore, Michael (Sept 30 2009).Greed killed the newspapers. YouTube. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F9pYp2M4444.Nov 15 2010.
2- Chomsky, Noam (May 21 2009). Manufacturing Consent. YouTube. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OJuqoDvyXOk. Nov 15 2010
Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Can citizen journalism and/or cyber technology raise global awareness?
Cyber technology is global as it is and the researcher can find information about anything, from the weather in Australia to the prices of an item in another country.
Cyber technology can raise global awareness because of sites that provide valid information.
TheDis Appeal of Narratives
In the Tsunami article, Wilkes argues that in 2004 "distance in space," i.e geographical distance, had lost it's ability to barrier the travel of news in comparison to 1755. (Wilkes 49) Because of technology, the spread of news had become faster and more endurant.
In comparison to the Lisbon earth quake, the Tsunami recieved much more accurate, in depth, wide-spread and impactful news coverage. By this notion, one could assume that contemporary narratives (especially media events) are better than narratives of the past, which lacked the ability to include all that they do now.
However, the faith in these advancements is what gives that narrative the power to manipulate or deceive. In our discussions, the class talked about lonelygirl 15, who pretended to be a sad, young girl looking for friends. We've talked about facebook, and it's collection of personal information and target marketing. Both examples of deceit, where audiences trusted the reality of the media. These examples serve as a warning that individuals and organizations have power to create mass-deception, just as they do to create mass-awareness.
Wilkes article includes a picture (figure 4.1 and 4.2) of the aftermath in the Lisbon earthquake, as examples of individual conceptions of the earthquakes aftermath. The pictures depict "dramatic, visually stirring" renditions of homes being carried away and screaming faces. He points out that without technology, accuracy was of opinion and depended on the correspondent. (Wilkes55) Historically, events and their representation, were subject to the elite and the few, i.e those who could travel, those who could draw, those who were wealthy enough to learn and do both.
Really, not much has changed. Facebook has an incredible power through their networking capabilities, and while they and lonelygirl15, and the Tsunami are more tied to realistic representations, they still have a plethera of images, videos and mediums to use in order to skew perspective.
Works Cited
Wilke, Jurgen: Historical Perspectives on Media Events: a Comparison of the Lisbon Earthquake in 1755 and the Tsunami Catastrophe in 2004. In: Couldry, Nick (ed.): Media Events in a Global Age, Chapter 4, pp. 45-60.
Abbott: The Cambridge Introduction to Narrative.
Herman: The Cambridge Companion to Narrative.
Thorne, Alexis. Global Media Narrative Definitions.
Narrative Appeal: Social Constraints of Empathy and Hegemonic Influence
Some blame of the marked disparity between coverage of stories and audience reception of narrative discourses must go to the generally immutable need for receivers of news to identify with a specific character. The emergence of the late Neda Agha-Soltan as a quintessential victim of oppressive an Iranian old guard, was enabled by the dramatic footage captured on video-phones by civilians near her (Fahti, 2009) as well as the fact that the bullet hit her in her torso, not her head, thus preserving her beauty, even in death (Fischer, 2010). While the feminicidios in Ciudad Juarez are most frequently of young, attractive women, evidence of their deaths are generally recognized only upon the discovery of “decomposed bodies...often unidentifiable” (Livingston, 2004, p. 59), so there is a scarcity of photographic journalistic representation of the victims as living people, not just as corpses.
Anthropologist Robin Dunbar formulated a numerical limit to the number of people that an individual is capable of having personal contacts (Bialic, 2007). There must also be a limit to the number of people that an individual can deeply empathize with, as opposed to merely pitying on a rationally moral basis. The latter is seldom as effective as the former in galvanizing support for a cause.
There is also no doubt that the preferences of audience members can be largely influenced by the cumulative manipulation of hegemonic influences, and subsequent reinforcement by group mentality in a viral fashion, as evidenced by the effectiveness of astroturfing. These more surreptitious modes of influencing news content have been criticized in detail by voices such as Chomsky (Achbar, 1992). Proponents of deeper investigations into the murders in Ciudad Juarez suspect that their detractors are “a front for the state government” (Livingston, 2004, p. 64).
References
Achbar, M. (producer). (1992). Manufacturing consent: Noam Chomsky and the media. Retrieved October 16, 2010 from http://www.youtube.com
Bialic, C. (2007, Novermber 16). Sorry, you may have gone over your limit of network friends. The Wall Street Journal, p. B1. Retrieved October 16, 2010 from http://online.wsj.com/article/SB119518271549595364.html?mod=googlenews_wsj
Fahti, N. (2009, June 23). In a death seen around the world, a symbol of Iranian protests. The New York Times, p. A1. Retrieved October 16, 2010 from http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/23/world/middleeast/23neda.html?_r=1
Fischer, A. (2010). Global media narratives in the digital age (lecture). Binghamton University.
Livingston, J. (2004). Murder in Juarez: Gender, sexual violence, and the global assembly line. Frontiers: A Journal of Women Studies, 25, 59-76.
Can citizen journalism and/or cyber technology raise global awareness?
Cyber Technology Can Raise Global Awareness
What is an appealing narrative?/What is the disappeal of narrative?
What is an appealing narrative?
What makes a narrative appealing? I think this is better to work for for me. Although I concede that there may be other elements that make a narrative appealing...what I believe I am focusing on with the response is why is it that some narratives proliferate while others remain unnoticed. Narratives proliferate based on their potential for becoming commodified--how well these narratives can be "sold" to us. When dealing with traditional/major news sources, it is obvious (to the critical mind) that the narratives which are chosen to be aired are always within the realm of corporate interest. So what is appealing to these news sources--is their ability to reinforce the values and identities which serve corporate interest.
When looking at narratives which are proliferated outside of these traditional media organizations, it is not as apparent how it is that one narrative will be chosen over another--what makes it appealing. I would still make the argument that the narratives which are found to be appealing somehow reinforce the values and pre-existing narratives which are already in place in our capitalist centered culture. The story of Neda exemplifies this well--for as we observed in class, what is appealing about Neda is that she is young, beautiful, and most importantly WESTERNIZED! The Iranian protest would have never received as much attention as it did if it was not for the video of her shooting being circulated on Youtube. If Neda has been wearing traditional garb, I do not think that people would have paid her as much attention. Her image represents and symbolizes Western presence. There hundreds of thousands of women in these countries being tortured in much more severe manners--and their stories are not viral on Youtube.
What is the disappeal of narrative?
The disappeal of narrative to me is its structure. Its association with story-telling-- its reliance on "somthing" happening. It is restrictive in that by its form it is already limiting the kinds of information which receive attention. There is no such thing as a narrative which is not hegemonic. Narratives will always leave out other perspectives BECAUSE of their form.
Can citizen journalism and/or cyber technology raise global awareness?
Thus cyber technology also plays a key in raising global awareness. With the capabilities of technology through the usage of cell phone and laptops, people are able to capture videos or pictures of the events that occurred. Sometimes these videos are posted on youtube or other social sites, where it becomes available to everyone. The news might spread through people that have viewed it on these social sites, and have told their friends about it. Thus this process sometimes spreads news faster than if you were to read it on a newspaper the next day. And certain news that the media have taught to be less significant previously might suddenly become significant after an increase in global awareness.